Compare
Practice Claim RCM vs In-House Billing
An honest side-by-side look at outsourcing your billing to us versus running it with your own staff, including when keeping it in house is the better choice.
Which is better for your practice?
In-house billing gives you direct control, but its costs are fixed and its results depend on a small number of people. Practice Claim RCM charges a percentage of what we collect, from 2.49% of net collections, and brings a certified team, set follow-up rules and monthly reporting. Outsourcing tends to fit practices with staff turnover, rising denials or growing A/R. In-house billing can be the better choice for practices that already have an experienced team and strong numbers.
Side by side
How the two models compare
How you pay
Practice Claim RCMA percentage of net collections, from 2.49% for higher-volume practices, quoted in writing after a free audit
In-house billing teamSalaries, benefits, payroll taxes, software, clearinghouse and training, paid whether collections rise or fall
Cost when collections drop
Practice Claim RCMThe fee drops with collections. You never pay on uncollected claims
In-house billing teamStaff and software costs stay the same
Setup and software fees
Practice Claim RCMNone for full-service billing
In-house billing teamYour own software and clearinghouse licenses
Coverage during absences and turnover
Practice Claim RCMA billing team with a named account lead
In-house billing teamDepends on your staff. Claims can stall during vacations, sick leave and hiring
Coding
Practice Claim RCMAAPC and AHIMA certified coders
In-house billing teamDepends on who you hire and the training you fund
Claim follow-up
Practice Claim RCMDaily claim submission, follow-up on any claim with no payer response after 30 days, weekly aging reviews
In-house billing teamSet by your team's capacity and process
Reporting
Practice Claim RCMMonthly report on clean claim rate, denials by payer and reason, days in A/R, A/R over 90 days and net collection rate
In-house billing teamWhatever your team builds and maintains
Control
Practice Claim RCMShared. You see results monthly and set the scope in writing
In-house billing teamDirect. Your staff work on site and answer to you
HIPAA
Practice Claim RCMA mutual Business Associate Agreement signed before any data is shared
In-house billing teamCovered by your own policies and staff training
Time to start
Practice Claim RCMOnboarding in 2 to 4 weeks
In-house billing teamHiring and training time for each new biller
| Practice Claim RCM | In-house billing team | |
|---|---|---|
| How you pay | A percentage of net collections, from 2.49% for higher-volume practices, quoted in writing after a free audit | Salaries, benefits, payroll taxes, software, clearinghouse and training, paid whether collections rise or fall |
| Cost when collections drop | The fee drops with collections. You never pay on uncollected claims | Staff and software costs stay the same |
| Setup and software fees | None for full-service billing | Your own software and clearinghouse licenses |
| Coverage during absences and turnover | A billing team with a named account lead | Depends on your staff. Claims can stall during vacations, sick leave and hiring |
| Coding | AAPC and AHIMA certified coders | Depends on who you hire and the training you fund |
| Claim follow-up | Daily claim submission, follow-up on any claim with no payer response after 30 days, weekly aging reviews | Set by your team's capacity and process |
| Reporting | Monthly report on clean claim rate, denials by payer and reason, days in A/R, A/R over 90 days and net collection rate | Whatever your team builds and maintains |
| Control | Shared. You see results monthly and set the scope in writing | Direct. Your staff work on site and answer to you |
| HIPAA | A mutual Business Associate Agreement signed before any data is shared | Covered by your own policies and staff training |
| Time to start | Onboarding in 2 to 4 weeks | Hiring and training time for each new biller |
Fit
When each option makes sense
In-house billing may fit better when
- You have an experienced biller or team with low turnover.
- Your denial rate, days in A/R and net collection rate already meet benchmarks.
- Your workflows are unusual enough that on-site billing staff save real time.
- You want billing staff on site and reporting directly to you.
Outsourcing may fit better when
- Billing stalls when someone is out or leaves.
- Denials are rising or A/R over 90 days keeps growing.
- You want billing costs to rise and fall with collections.
- Nobody has time to track payer rule changes, appeals and old claims.
- You want monthly KPI reporting without building it yourself.
Cost
A worked cost example
Here is the arithmetic for one example practice. These are example inputs, not averages: $150,000 in monthly collections, two full-time billers at $45,000 a year each, 25% for benefits and payroll taxes, and $1,000 a month for software, clearinghouse and other overhead.
Your own numbers will differ. The calculator lets you enter them, and your free audit gives you a written rate.
Open the billing cost calculatorIn-house team
Per year$124,500
Share6.9%
Outsourced at 4%
Per year$72,000
Share4.0%
Outsourced at 2.49%
Per year$44,820
Share2.49%
| Option | Per year | Share |
|---|---|---|
| In-house team | $124,500 | 6.9% |
| Outsourced at 4% | $72,000 | 4.0% |
| Outsourced at 2.49% | $44,820 | 2.49% |
Example only. 2.49% is our starting rate for higher-volume practices; your rate depends on specialty, volume and scope.
Switching
What switching to Practice Claim RCM involves
- 1
Free 90-day audit
We review your claims, denials and A/R aging under a signed BAA and send a line-item report in 5 to 7 business days.
- 2
Written quote and scope
You get your rate and a sample service agreement, with contract length and notice period, before you commit.
- 3
Onboarding in 2 to 4 weeks
We connect to your existing EHR and clearinghouse. Your schedule and charting workflow stay the same.
- 4
Monthly reporting
A named account lead and a monthly KPI report by payer and provider.
Frequently asked questions
Is outsourcing always cheaper than in-house billing?
Can we keep some billing work in house?
What happens to our current billing staff?
Do we have to change our EHR or practice management system?
How long does switching take?
How do we keep visibility into our billing?
Ready to see where your revenue cycle stands?
Request a free 90-day audit. We review your claims, denials and A/R aging under a signed BAA and send a line-item report in 5 to 7 business days.