By the Practice Claim RCM billing team. Updated .
Short answer
Claim adjustment reason codes (CARCs) explain why a payer paid a claim differently than billed. They appear on the remittance with a group code: CO for contractual obligation, PR for patient responsibility, OA for other adjustments and PI for payer-initiated reductions. Remittance advice remark codes (RARCs) add detail.
How to read a denial on the remittance
Each adjustment on an 835 electronic remittance or paper EOB has a group code and a reason code, such as CO-97. The group code tells you who is responsible for the amount. The reason code tells you why. A remark code, such as N130 or M127, often explains what the payer needs.
CO adjustments generally cannot be billed to the patient. PR adjustments, such as deductible and coinsurance, can be. OA and PI are used for other situations, such as coordination of benefits and payer reductions.
CO
MeaningContractual obligation
Can the patient be billed?Generally no
PR
MeaningPatient responsibility
Can the patient be billed?Yes, under your financial policy
OA
MeaningOther adjustment
Can the patient be billed?Depends on the reason code
PI
MeaningPayer-initiated reduction
Can the patient be billed?Generally no
| Group code | Meaning | Can the patient be billed? |
|---|---|---|
| CO | Contractual obligation | Generally no |
| PR | Patient responsibility | Yes, under your financial policy |
| OA | Other adjustment | Depends on the reason code |
| PI | Payer-initiated reduction | Generally no |
Common denial codes and fixes
CARC 16
What it meansClaim lacks information or has a submission or billing error
How to fix and prevent itRead the remark code, correct the missing data and resubmit. Prevent with claim scrubbing.
CARC 4
What it meansProcedure code is inconsistent with the modifier, or a required modifier is missing
How to fix and prevent itCorrect the modifier and resubmit. Add payer modifier rules to your scrubber.
CARC 11
What it meansDiagnosis is inconsistent with the procedure
How to fix and prevent itCheck documentation and the payer's covered diagnosis list, then correct or appeal.
CARC 18
What it meansExact duplicate claim or service
How to fix and prevent itCheck claim status before resubmitting. Use a corrected claim frequency code for changes.
CARC 22
What it meansCare may be covered by another payer per coordination of benefits
How to fix and prevent itConfirm primary coverage with the patient and payer, then bill the primary.
CARC 27
What it meansExpenses incurred after coverage terminated
How to fix and prevent itVerify eligibility, find current coverage and bill the right payer.
CARC 29
What it meansTime limit for filing has expired
How to fix and prevent itAppeal only with proof of timely filing. Prevent with daily charge entry and rejection work.
CARC 50
What it meansNot deemed a medical necessity by the payer
How to fix and prevent itAppeal with records that support necessity. Check coverage policies before the service.
CARC 96
What it meansNon-covered charge
How to fix and prevent itConfirm benefits. Bill the patient only if a valid waiver or notice was signed.
CARC 97
What it meansBenefit is included in payment for another service already adjudicated
How to fix and prevent itCheck bundling edits. Add a modifier only when documentation supports a separate service.
CARC 109
What it meansClaim not covered by this payer; send to the correct payer
How to fix and prevent itIdentify the correct payer or plan, such as a managed care plan, and rebill.
CARC 197
What it meansPrecertification or authorization absent
How to fix and prevent itRequest a retro authorization if the payer allows it. Prevent with authorization checks before scheduling.
CARC 1, 2, 3
What it meansDeductible, coinsurance and copay amounts
How to fix and prevent itNot a denial. Bill the patient the PR amount under your financial policy.
| Code | What it means | How to fix and prevent it |
|---|---|---|
| CARC 16 | Claim lacks information or has a submission or billing error | Read the remark code, correct the missing data and resubmit. Prevent with claim scrubbing. |
| CARC 4 | Procedure code is inconsistent with the modifier, or a required modifier is missing | Correct the modifier and resubmit. Add payer modifier rules to your scrubber. |
| CARC 11 | Diagnosis is inconsistent with the procedure | Check documentation and the payer's covered diagnosis list, then correct or appeal. |
| CARC 18 | Exact duplicate claim or service | Check claim status before resubmitting. Use a corrected claim frequency code for changes. |
| CARC 22 | Care may be covered by another payer per coordination of benefits | Confirm primary coverage with the patient and payer, then bill the primary. |
| CARC 27 | Expenses incurred after coverage terminated | Verify eligibility, find current coverage and bill the right payer. |
| CARC 29 | Time limit for filing has expired | Appeal only with proof of timely filing. Prevent with daily charge entry and rejection work. |
| CARC 50 | Not deemed a medical necessity by the payer | Appeal with records that support necessity. Check coverage policies before the service. |
| CARC 96 | Non-covered charge | Confirm benefits. Bill the patient only if a valid waiver or notice was signed. |
| CARC 97 | Benefit is included in payment for another service already adjudicated | Check bundling edits. Add a modifier only when documentation supports a separate service. |
| CARC 109 | Claim not covered by this payer; send to the correct payer | Identify the correct payer or plan, such as a managed care plan, and rebill. |
| CARC 197 | Precertification or authorization absent | Request a retro authorization if the payer allows it. Prevent with authorization checks before scheduling. |
| CARC 1, 2, 3 | Deductible, coinsurance and copay amounts | Not a denial. Bill the patient the PR amount under your financial policy. |
Fix the cause, not just the claim
Most denials repeat. Track denials by code, payer, provider and location each month, and fix the step in the workflow where the problem starts. A rising count of CARC 197 points to scheduling and authorization; CARC 16 and 4 point to charge entry and scrubbing; CARC 27 and 22 point to eligibility checks.
- Front end: eligibility, coordination of benefits and authorization checks before the visit.
- Mid cycle: coding review, modifier rules and claim scrubbing before submission.
- Back end: appeals with complete records, filed well inside the payer's appeal window.
Sources
This guide is general information, not legal advice. Rules change and payer contracts vary, so confirm current requirements with each payer.