By the Practice Claim RCM billing team. Updated .
Short answer
The best time to collect a patient balance is at the visit, before the patient leaves. Tell the patient the amount before the visit, ask for payment directly at check-in, and offer a clear alternative such as a card on file or a payment plan. For past-due balances, call early, state the amount and date of service, and ask for payment on the call. Keep the tone factual and polite.
Before the visit
"Hi, this is [name] from [practice]. I am calling to confirm your appointment on [date]. Based on your insurance, your copay for this visit is [amount], and you have [amount] left on your deductible. We collect the copay at check-in. Would you like to pay now by card so check-in is faster?"
At check-in
"Your copay today is [amount]. How would you like to pay, card or cash?"
If there is a past balance: "I also see a balance of [amount] from your visit on [date]. Can we take care of that today as well?"
Past-due balance call
"Hi, this is [name] from [practice] billing. I am calling about a balance of [amount] for your visit on [date]. Your insurance has processed the claim and this is your share. Can I take a payment over the phone today?"
Common objections
"My insurance should cover this."
Response"Your plan processed the claim and applied [amount] to your deductible. I can send you the explanation from your insurance so you can see the detail."
"I cannot pay all of it now."
Response"I understand. We can set up a payment plan of [amount] a month. Would that work?"
"I never got a bill."
Response"I am sorry about that. Let me confirm your address and email, and I will send it today. Would you like to pay now while we are on the phone?"
"I want to talk to my insurance first."
Response"That is fine. Here is the claim number and date of service. I will note your account and follow up on [date]."
| The patient says | Response |
|---|---|
| "My insurance should cover this." | "Your plan processed the claim and applied [amount] to your deductible. I can send you the explanation from your insurance so you can see the detail." |
| "I cannot pay all of it now." | "I understand. We can set up a payment plan of [amount] a month. Would that work?" |
| "I never got a bill." | "I am sorry about that. Let me confirm your address and email, and I will send it today. Would you like to pay now while we are on the phone?" |
| "I want to talk to my insurance first." | "That is fine. Here is the claim number and date of service. I will note your account and follow up on [date]." |
Rules to follow
- Give uninsured and self-pay patients a good faith estimate when they schedule. If the final bill is at least $400 above the estimate, they can dispute it.
- Never threaten collections or credit reporting unless that is the written policy and you are ready to follow it.
- Confirm identity before discussing any balance, and do not leave balance details on a voicemail others may hear.
- Write down the result of every call in the account notes.
- Follow your state's rules and your practice's written financial policy.
Sources
- CMS: Good faith estimate and patient-provider dispute resolution for uninsured or self-pay individuals
- CMS: Providers, payment resolution with patients
This guide is general information, not legal advice. Rules change and payer contracts vary, so confirm current requirements with each payer.