By the Practice Claim RCM billing team. Updated .
Short answer
In-house billing gives you direct control but depends on hiring, training and keeping billing staff, plus software and clearinghouse costs. Outsourced billing turns those costs into a fee tied to collections and adds coverage across coding, A/R and credentialing. The right choice depends on your cost to collect, denial rate and A/R today.
Side-by-side comparison
Cost structure
In-houseSalaries, benefits, software, clearinghouse, training
OutsourcedFee based on collections, per claim or flat
Coverage
In-houseDepends on how many staff you have
OutsourcedTeam coverage during leave and turnover
Expertise
In-houseLimited to your staff's experience
OutsourcedCoders, A/R and credentialing specialists
Control
In-houseDirect day-to-day control
OutsourcedControl through reporting, contract terms and system access
Scaling
In-houseHire and train for each increase
OutsourcedCapacity added by the billing company
Data
In-houseIn your systems
OutsourcedStays in your systems when the company works in them
| Factor | In-house | Outsourced |
|---|---|---|
| Cost structure | Salaries, benefits, software, clearinghouse, training | Fee based on collections, per claim or flat |
| Coverage | Depends on how many staff you have | Team coverage during leave and turnover |
| Expertise | Limited to your staff's experience | Coders, A/R and credentialing specialists |
| Control | Direct day-to-day control | Control through reporting, contract terms and system access |
| Scaling | Hire and train for each increase | Capacity added by the billing company |
| Data | In your systems | Stays in your systems when the company works in them |
Calculate your in-house cost to collect
Cost to collect is your total billing cost divided by your total collections for the same period. Add up a full year of these costs and divide by a year of collections:
- Salaries and benefits for everyone who works on billing, including part of the office manager's time.
- Practice management software and clearinghouse fees.
- Statement printing and postage.
- Training, certifications and coding resources.
- Recruiting and lost productivity from turnover.
- Revenue lost to timely filing, write-offs and unworked denials.
Signs it is time to outsource
- Denials are rising and no one has time to find the cause.
- A/R over 90 days keeps growing.
- Billing depends on one person.
- New providers wait months to be credentialed.
- You cannot get clear monthly numbers on collections and denials.
When in-house billing works well
In-house billing can work well when you have experienced, stable staff, a low denial rate, current A/R and reporting you trust. Many practices also use a hybrid: front desk collections and charge entry in-house, with claims, denials and A/R outsourced.
Start with your own numbers
Before deciding, measure your current results: collections, denial rate, first-pass resolution rate, days in A/R and A/R over 90 days. Our free 90-day audit gives you those numbers from your own data, whether or not you decide to outsource.